Craig Cay

Craig Cay, located just south of Islamorada at Mile Marker 71.2 (bayside) recently sold for $8.6 million.

Craig Cay, a new mid-construction Bespoke luxury home on more than 1.5 acres, has traded hands for $8.6 million, making it the highest sale in the Florida Keys outside of the Ocean Reef Club since 2017, according to the listing agents.

Kelly K. Shaw and Trent M. P. Shaw of American Caribbean/Christie’s International Real Estate held the listing and procured the buyer.

This is the 10th sale north of $5 million in 2020, with American Caribbean Real Estate participating in a third of those transactions. This deal comes on the heels of the sale of Ballast Trail, which closed in July for $6.7 million, the second-highest sale of 2020. Kelly and Trent Shaw held the listing for this sale as well.

Igmar Enterprises, LLC is the builder of the Craig Cay estate, which was sold under construction. The 9,737-square-foot home just south of Islamorada features six bedrooms, six full baths, two half baths, an exercise room, glass solarium, three-car garage with guest quarters, a boat basin with 106 feet of concrete dock and a 222-foot-long pool wrapping around two sides of the home.

Recommended for you